Proposal Evaluation Form for the United Kingdom

Proposal Evaluation Form Template for England and Wales

A Proposal Evaluation Form is a standardized document used in England and Wales for assessing and scoring submitted proposals in a systematic and transparent manner. It provides a framework for evaluators to assess proposals against predetermined criteria, ensuring compliance with public procurement regulations and maintaining fairness in the selection process. The document includes scoring matrices, evaluation criteria, and detailed assessment guidelines, facilitating objective decision-making and providing an audit trail for the evaluation process.

Your data doesn't train Genie's AI

You keep IP ownership of your information

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Download a Standard Template

4.6 / 5
4.8 / 5
Access for free
OR

Alternatively: Run an advanced review of an existing
Proposal Evaluation Form

Let Genie AI's market-leading legal AI identify missing terms, unusual language, compliance issues and more - in just seconds.
Upload your Doc

What is a Proposal Evaluation Form?

The Proposal Evaluation Form is a critical document in the procurement process under English and Welsh law, designed to ensure fair, transparent, and objective assessment of proposals. This document type is essential when organizations need to evaluate competing bids or proposals systematically. The form typically includes detailed evaluation criteria, scoring methodologies, and assessment guidelines, enabling evaluators to make informed decisions while maintaining compliance with public procurement regulations. The document serves as both a working tool during the evaluation process and as an audit record of the decision-making process.

What sections should be included in a Proposal Evaluation Form?

1. Proposal Information: Basic details about the proposal including proposal reference number, submitting organization, date of submission, and contact details

2. Evaluation Criteria: Detailed breakdown of assessment criteria and their respective weightings, including minimum qualifying scores if applicable

3. Scoring Matrix: Definition of the scoring system, scoring methodology, and interpretation guidelines for each score level

4. Evaluator Information: Details of evaluation team members, their roles, responsibilities, and relevant expertise

5. Assessment Summary: Overall evaluation results, total scores, key findings, strengths, weaknesses, and final recommendations

What sections are optional to include in a Proposal Evaluation Form?

1. Technical Assessment: Detailed evaluation of technical aspects, specifications, and proposed solutions - used for proposals with significant technical components

2. Financial Assessment: In-depth evaluation of financial elements, cost analysis, and value for money assessment - used when proposal includes substantial financial considerations

3. Risk Assessment: Comprehensive evaluation of potential risks, mitigation strategies, and impact analysis - recommended for high-value or high-risk proposals

What schedules should be included in a Proposal Evaluation Form?

1. Schedule 1 - Scoring Guidelines: Detailed guidance document for evaluators explaining how to apply scoring criteria consistently

2. Schedule 2 - Evaluation Matrix Template: Standardized template for recording individual evaluations and comments

3. Schedule 3 - Conflict of Interest Declarations: Standard forms for evaluators to declare any potential conflicts of interest

4. Schedule 4 - Technical Requirements Checklist: Comprehensive checklist for evaluating technical compliance and specifications

Authors

Alex Denne

Head of Growth (Open Source Law) @ Genie AI | 3 x UCL-Certified in Contract Law & Drafting | 4+ Years Managing 1M+ Legal Documents | Serial Founder & Legal AI Author

Jurisdiction

England and Wales

Publisher

Genie AI

Document Type

Evaluation Form

Cost

Free to use
Relevant legal definitions
Clauses
Industries

Public Contracts Regulations 2015: Primary legislation governing public procurement processes in England and Wales, including proposal evaluation procedures and criteria

Utilities Contracts Regulations 2016: Specific regulations for procurement in utilities sectors including water, energy, transport and postal services

Concession Contracts Regulations 2016: Regulations governing the award of concession contracts by public authorities and utilities

UK General Data Protection Regulation (UK GDPR): Legislation governing the processing and handling of personal data, relevant for storing and processing proposal information

Data Protection Act 2018: UK's implementation of data protection standards, complementing UK GDPR requirements

Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR): Specific rules for privacy in electronic communications, relevant for digital proposal submissions

Competition Act 1998: Legislation ensuring fair competition and preventing anti-competitive practices in procurement processes

Enterprise Act 2002: Framework for business regulation and competition law enforcement

Equality Act 2010: Legislation ensuring non-discrimination and equal treatment in evaluation processes

Freedom of Information Act 2000: Legislation governing public access to information held by public authorities, including proposal evaluation records

Companies Act 2006: Corporate governance requirements affecting proposal evaluation and business relationships

Local Government Transparency Code: Guidelines for transparency in local government procurement and evaluation processes

Environmental Legislation: Various environmental laws and regulations that may affect proposal evaluation criteria and requirements

EU Retained Law: Former EU legislation retained in UK law post-Brexit affecting procurement and evaluation processes

Teams

Employer, Employee, Start Date, Job Title, Department, Location, Probationary Period, Notice Period, Salary, Overtime, Vacation Pay, Statutory Holidays, Benefits, Bonus, Expenses, Working Hours, Rest Breaks,  Leaves of Absence, Confidentiality, Intellectual Property, Non-Solicitation, Non-Competition, Code of Conduct, Termination,  Severance Pay, Governing Law, Entire Agreemen

Find the exact document you need

Lecturer Evaluation Form

A standardized template for evaluating academic teaching staff performance in England and Wales, compliant with UK education regulations and employment law.

find out more

60 Day Evaluation

An English law agreement enabling structured evaluation of products or services over a 60-day period.

find out more

30 Day Employee Evaluation

A standardized template for evaluating new employees after 30 days of employment, compliant with English and Welsh employment law.

find out more

Skill Evaluation Skills Assessment

A legally compliant skills assessment template for professional competency evaluation under England and Wales jurisdiction.

find out more

Evaluation Questionnaire

A standardized template under English and Welsh law used to evaluate potential suppliers' capabilities and compliance for specific projects or contracts.

find out more

6 Month Evaluation

An English law-governed template for conducting structured six-month employee evaluations.

find out more

Bonus Evaluation

A standardized template under English and Welsh law for evaluating and documenting employee performance for bonus determination purposes.

find out more

Coaching Evaluation

A standardized template for evaluating coaching effectiveness and progress, compliant with English and Welsh law.

find out more

Work Evaluation

A legally compliant employee evaluation framework under English and Welsh law for systematic performance assessment.

find out more

Training Evaluation Survey

A standardized template for evaluating training effectiveness, compliant with England and Wales regulations and data protection laws.

find out more

Service Evaluation

A standardized template for evaluating service delivery performance under English and Welsh law.

find out more

Employee Annual Review

A legally compliant template for conducting annual employee performance reviews under England and Wales law.

find out more

Bid Evaluation

A standardized framework for evaluating tender submissions under English and Welsh law, ensuring fair and transparent bid assessment.

find out more

Annual Review Letter

A standardized template for documenting annual employee performance reviews under English and Welsh law.

find out more

Student Performance Evaluation

A legally compliant template for student performance evaluation in educational institutions under English and Welsh law.

find out more

Activity Evaluation Form

A standardized template for evaluating activities and programs under English and Welsh law, ensuring consistent assessment and compliance with UK regulations.

find out more

60 Day Employee Performance Review

A legally compliant template under English and Welsh law for conducting employee performance reviews during their first 60 days of employment.

find out more

Company Evaluation

A structured template under English and Welsh law for comprehensive company evaluation and assessment.

find out more

Nonprofit Executive Director Performance Evaluation

A standardized template for evaluating nonprofit Executive Directors' performance under English and Welsh law.

find out more

Dentist Appraisal

A standardized template for conducting dental practitioner appraisals in England and Wales, aligned with GDC requirements.

find out more

Staff Evaluation

A legally compliant staff evaluation framework for use in England and Wales, enabling structured employee performance assessment.

find out more

Department Evaluation

A standardized template for department evaluation under English and Welsh law, providing a framework for assessing departmental performance and compliance.

find out more

Construction Project Evaluation

A standardized template for evaluating construction project performance under English and Welsh law, ensuring comprehensive assessment of project outcomes and compliance.

find out more

Commercial Bid Evaluation

A standardized template for evaluating commercial bids under English and Welsh law, ensuring fair and transparent procurement processes.

find out more

Leadership Evaluation

A legally compliant leadership evaluation framework for use in England and Wales, designed to assess and document leadership performance and development.

find out more

Health And Safety Performance Review

A template for conducting health and safety performance reviews in accordance with English and Welsh health and safety legislation.

find out more

Product Assessment

A standardized template for product evaluation and compliance assessment under English and Welsh law.

find out more

Sales Performance Evaluation

A legally compliant template under English and Welsh law for evaluating sales personnel performance and achievement against targets.

find out more

Project Feedback

A standardized template for collecting and documenting project feedback, designed for use under English and Welsh law.

find out more

Board Self Assessment

A governance tool under English and Welsh law for evaluating board effectiveness and compliance with UK corporate governance requirements.

find out more

Vendor Assessment

A standardized template under English and Welsh law for evaluating vendor suitability, compliance, and risk factors.

find out more

360 Degree Feedback

A legally compliant template for conducting 360-degree feedback assessments under English and Welsh law, including guidelines and safeguards for all participants.

find out more

Self Evaluation

A legally compliant template for employee self-assessment under English and Welsh law.

find out more

Truck Driver Evaluation Form

An England & Wales document assessing commercial vehicle driver performance for regulatory compliance and safety standards.

find out more

Training Evaluation Form For Employees

An England & Wales document collecting feedback on employee training effectiveness for compliance and development purposes.

find out more

Training Appraisal Form

An England & Wales document assessing training effectiveness, ensuring compliance and supporting organizational development objectives.

find out more

Trainer Performance Evaluation Form

An England & Wales document assessing training delivery effectiveness and supporting trainer professional development.

find out more

Teacher Evaluation Form Doc

An England & Wales document assessing teaching effectiveness and compliance with educational standards and legislation.

find out more

Tasting Form

An England & Wales document for structured product evaluations ensuring compliance with food safety and consumer protection laws.

find out more

Supervisor Assessment Form

A performance evaluation document in England & Wales, assessing employee achievements and development for HR compliance.

find out more
See more related templates

Genie’s Security Promise

Genie is the safest place to draft. Here’s how we prioritise your privacy and security.

Your documents are private:

We do not train on your data; Genie’s AI improves independently

All data stored on Genie is private to your organisation

Your documents are protected:

Your documents are protected by ultra-secure 256-bit encryption

We are ISO27001 certified, so your data is secure

Organizational security:

You retain IP ownership of your documents and their information

You have full control over your data and who gets to see it

2 Docs LeftAccess Now