Vetting and Selecting a Custom Software Development Agency: Legal Due Diligence Checklist

Vetting and Selecting a Custom Software Development Agency: Legal Due Diligence Checklist

Selecting a custom software development agency is a high-stakes decision that can shape your company's digital capabilities for years to come. Beyond evaluating technical skills and portfolios, commercial teams must conduct thorough legal due diligence to protect their organization from risk. This checklist provides a practical framework for assessing agencies from a contracts and compliance perspective.

Corporate Structure and Financial Stability

Before signing any agreement, verify the agency's legal standing and financial health. Request a certificate of good standing from the state where the agency is incorporated, and confirm that the entity is authorized to conduct business in your jurisdiction. This step prevents future complications if disputes arise or if you need to enforce contract terms.

Financial stability matters because software development projects often span months or years. Ask for recent financial statements or credit references to assess whether the agency can sustain operations throughout your project timeline. If the agency is a startup or smaller firm, consider requesting a parent company guarantee or performance bond to mitigate the risk of project abandonment.

Insurance Coverage and Risk Transfer

A reputable custom software development agency should carry adequate insurance coverage. At minimum, require proof of current general liability insurance, professional liability coverage (errors and omissions), and cyber liability insurance. The policy limits should be proportionate to your project's value and potential exposure.

Review the agency's standard indemnification clauses carefully. These provisions determine who bears responsibility when third-party claims arise from intellectual property infringement, data breaches, or other issues. Ensure that indemnification obligations are mutual and reasonable, with appropriate carve-outs for each party's negligence or willful misconduct.

Intellectual Property Ownership and Licensing

Intellectual property provisions often become the most contentious aspect of software development contracts. Clarify upfront who will own the custom code, documentation, and related deliverables. Most clients expect to own all work product created specifically for their project, but agencies may resist transferring ownership of pre-existing code libraries, frameworks, or tools they bring to the engagement.

A balanced approach involves the agency granting you a perpetual, irrevocable license to use any pre-existing components incorporated into your custom solution, while you retain full ownership of the bespoke code written for your specifications. Document these arrangements explicitly in the master services agreement, and ensure the agency represents that it has the authority to grant such rights without infringing on third-party intellectual property.

Data Security and Privacy Compliance

If your project involves processing customer data, employee information, or other sensitive content, the agency must demonstrate robust data security practices. Request copies of the agency's information security policies, incident response procedures, and any relevant compliance certifications such as SOC 2, ISO 27001, or industry-specific standards.

Address data protection obligations directly in your contract. Specify where data will be stored, who can access it, and how it will be secured during development and testing. If your business is subject to regulations like HIPAA, GDPR, or state privacy laws, the agency must agree to comply with applicable requirements and sign a data processing addendum or business associate agreement as needed.

Subcontracting and Personnel Controls

Many agencies rely on subcontractors or offshore development teams to deliver projects. Understand the agency's subcontracting practices and require advance written notice before any subcontractors are engaged. Your contract should include a Main Contractor And Subcontractor Agreement framework that holds the agency responsible for subcontractor performance and ensures that all intellectual property and confidentiality obligations flow down to third parties.

Consider negotiating key personnel clauses that identify critical team members who will work on your project and restrict the agency from replacing them without your consent. This provision helps maintain continuity and prevents the agency from substituting experienced developers with junior staff after the contract is signed.

Payment Terms and Escrow Arrangements

Structure payment milestones around objective deliverables rather than time-based intervals. This approach aligns the agency's compensation with actual progress and gives you leverage if the project falls behind schedule or quality standards slip.

For larger engagements, consider establishing a source code escrow arrangement. Under this structure, the agency deposits the source code and documentation with a neutral third-party escrow agent, and you gain access if the agency fails to meet its obligations, goes out of business, or breaches the maintenance agreement. This safeguard ensures business continuity even if the relationship with the agency deteriorates.

Warranties, Acceptance Testing, and Support

Standard agency contracts often limit warranties to short periods or disclaim implied warranties entirely. Negotiate for meaningful warranty coverage that includes functionality warranties (the software will perform according to specifications), non-infringement warranties (the code does not violate third-party rights), and workmanship warranties (the code is free from material defects).

Define a clear acceptance testing process with specific criteria for evaluating deliverables. The contract should specify how long you have to test each milestone, what constitutes a defect versus a change request, and how the agency must remediate rejected work. Avoid open-ended acceptance provisions that allow agencies to declare work complete without your formal sign-off.

Post-launch support terms deserve equal attention. Clarify the duration of warranty support, response times for different severity levels, and whether bug fixes are included in the original price or billed separately. If you are purchasing ongoing maintenance services, ensure the Software Consulting Agreement includes service level commitments and remedies for non-performance.

Termination Rights and Transition Assistance

Even with careful vetting, some agency relationships do not work out. Your contract should include termination rights for cause (material breach, insolvency, failure to meet milestones) and potentially for convenience with adequate notice. Specify what happens to work product, payments, and intellectual property upon termination.

Require the agency to provide transition assistance if you terminate the relationship or choose not to renew. This obligation should include delivering all source code, documentation, passwords, and technical knowledge necessary for you or a replacement vendor to maintain and enhance the software. Set a reasonable fee for transition services if they extend beyond a brief handoff period.

Dispute Resolution and Governing Law

Specify the governing law and venue for resolving disputes in your contract. Most U.S. businesses prefer their home state law and courts, though agencies may push for their own jurisdiction. Consider whether mandatory arbitration or mediation clauses serve your interests, weighing the potential cost savings against reduced discovery rights and limited appeal options.

Include a detailed notice and cure process that requires parties to notify each other of potential breaches and allow a reasonable opportunity to remedy issues before pursuing formal legal action. This approach often resolves problems without litigation and demonstrates good faith if disputes do escalate.

Reference Checks and Past Performance

Legal due diligence extends beyond contract review. Contact the agency's previous clients, particularly those with similar project scope and complexity. Ask specific questions about how the agency handled change requests, whether they met deadlines, how they resolved disputes, and whether the client would engage them again.

Search court records and online databases for any litigation history involving the agency. While occasional disputes are normal in business, patterns of lawsuits over intellectual property, non-payment, or project failures should raise red flags.

Documentation and Record Keeping

Maintain organized records of all communications, change orders, and deliverables throughout the engagement. Require the agency to provide regular written status reports and document any deviations from the original scope or timeline. This documentation becomes critical if disputes arise or if you need to enforce contract terms.

Establish a formal change control process that requires written approval before the agency proceeds with any work outside the original statement of work. Verbal agreements and informal email exchanges often lead to disputes over scope creep and additional fees.

Final Contract Negotiation Strategy

Most agencies present standard form agreements that favor their interests. Do not assume these terms are non-negotiable. Commercial teams should systematically review every provision, identify unacceptable risks, and propose balanced alternatives. Focus your negotiation energy on the issues that matter most to your organization, such as intellectual property ownership, liability caps, and termination rights.

Engage legal counsel experienced in technology transactions to review the final agreement before signing. The cost of legal review is modest compared to the potential expense of litigation or a failed project. An experienced attorney can identify hidden risks and suggest protective provisions you might otherwise overlook.

Selecting a custom software development agency requires balancing technical capabilities with legal and financial safeguards. By conducting thorough due diligence and negotiating contracts that allocate risks appropriately, you position your organization for a successful partnership that delivers the digital solutions your business needs while protecting against downside scenarios. Take the time to get the legal foundation right, and you will avoid costly problems down the road.

What warranty provisions should you require from a software development agency?

Your contract with a custom software development agency should include clear warranty provisions that protect your investment. At minimum, require a warranty period covering defects in workmanship and code quality, typically ranging from 90 days to one year post-delivery. The agency should guarantee that deliverables meet agreed specifications, are free from material bugs, and do not infringe third-party intellectual property rights. Ensure the warranty obligates the agency to fix defects promptly at no additional cost. Consider negotiating separate warranties for different components, such as performance benchmarks or security standards. Document exclusions carefully, such as issues caused by your modifications or third-party integrations. These provisions establish accountability and provide recourse if the software fails to perform as promised, reducing your commercial risk significantly.

How do you verify a software agency's compliance with data protection regulations?

Verifying a custom software development agency's compliance with data protection regulations starts with requesting copies of their current certifications, such as ISO 27001 or SOC 2 attestations. Ask for documentation of their data handling policies, including data processing agreements that outline how they collect, store, and protect sensitive information. Review their incident response protocols and confirm they have appropriate technical safeguards like encryption and access controls. Request references from clients in regulated industries who can speak to the agency's compliance track record. Ensure the agency's contracts include clear data protection clauses, indemnification provisions, and audit rights. Finally, verify they maintain adequate cyber liability insurance and conduct regular third-party security assessments to stay current with evolving regulations.

What insurance coverage should your custom software development agency carry?

Your custom software development agency should maintain comprehensive insurance to protect against project failures, data breaches, and professional errors. At minimum, verify the agency carries professional liability insurance (also called errors and omissions insurance) covering software defects and missed deadlines. Cyber liability insurance is essential given the sensitive data developers access. General liability insurance protects against property damage or bodily injury claims. If the agency uses subcontractors, confirm they have workers' compensation and that subcontractor agreements include proper indemnification clauses. Request certificates of insurance showing adequate coverage limits, typically at least $1 million per occurrence. Ensure your company is named as an additional insured where appropriate, and verify policies remain active throughout the engagement period. Adequate insurance demonstrates financial stability and professional accountability.

Genie AI: The Global Contracting Standard

At Genie AI, we help founders and business leaders create, review, and manage tailored legal documents - without needing a legal team. Whether you're drafting documents, negotiating contracts, reviewing terms, or scaling operations whilst maintaining a lean team, Genie's AI-powered platform puts trusted legal workflows at your fingertips. Try Genie today and move faster, with legal clarity and confidence.