Employee Peer Evaluation Form for the United States

Employee Peer Evaluation Form Template for United States

A standardized form used in U.S. workplaces for employees to evaluate their peers' performance, skills, and contributions. This document complies with federal and state employment laws, including anti-discrimination provisions and privacy requirements. It provides a structured framework for objective feedback, promoting fair and constructive peer assessment while maintaining professional standards and legal compliance.

Your data doesn't train Genie's AI

You keep IP ownership of your information

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Download a Standard Template

4.6 / 5
4.8 / 5
Access for free
OR

Alternatively: Run an advanced review of an existing
Employee Peer Evaluation Form

Let Genie AI's market-leading legal AI identify missing terms, unusual language, compliance issues and more - in just seconds.
Upload your Doc

What is a Employee Peer Evaluation Form?

The Employee Peer Evaluation Form is a critical tool in modern U.S. workplace performance management systems. It enables organizations to gather comprehensive feedback about employees from their colleagues who work closely with them. This document is particularly valuable for annual reviews, project completions, or continuous improvement initiatives. The form typically includes rating scales, specific performance criteria, and space for detailed feedback while ensuring compliance with federal and state employment laws. It helps create a more rounded view of employee performance beyond traditional supervisor-only evaluations.

What sections should be included in a Employee Peer Evaluation Form?

1. Employee Information: Basic details of employee being evaluated and evaluator, including names, positions, department, and employee IDs

2. Evaluation Period: Timeframe covered by the evaluation, including start and end dates

3. Performance Criteria: Standard metrics for evaluation including teamwork, communication, technical skills, reliability, and initiative

4. Rating Scale Definition: Clear explanation of the rating system used (e.g., 1-5 scale, with definitions for each level)

5. Core Competencies Evaluation: Structured assessment of key competencies with rating and comments fields

6. Overall Feedback: Space for detailed comments, specific examples, and general observations

7. Signatures and Date: Space for evaluator signature, date, and any required acknowledgments

What sections are optional to include in a Employee Peer Evaluation Form?

1. Development Goals: Section for identifying areas of improvement and specific action items for future development

2. Project-Specific Evaluation: Additional section for evaluating performance on specific projects or initiatives

3. Self-Assessment Component: Space for employee self-evaluation to be completed before peer review

4. Performance Highlights: Section to highlight specific achievements or notable contributions during the evaluation period

What schedules should be included in a Employee Peer Evaluation Form?

1. Schedule A - Rating Scale Guide: Detailed explanation of rating criteria with specific examples for each level

2. Schedule B - Competency Definitions: Comprehensive definitions of each competency being evaluated

3. Schedule C - Previous Evaluation Summary: Summary of previous evaluation results for progress tracking (if applicable)

4. Schedule D - Behavioral Examples: Examples of behaviors that demonstrate different performance levels for each competency

Authors

Alex Denne

Head of Growth (Open Source Law) @ Genie AI | 3 x UCL-Certified in Contract Law & Drafting | 4+ Years Managing 1M+ Legal Documents | Serial Founder & Legal AI Author

Jurisdiction

United States

Publisher

Genie AI

Document Type

Evaluation Form

Cost

Free to use
Industries

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act 1964: Federal law that prohibits discrimination in employee evaluations based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. Must ensure evaluation criteria are non-discriminatory.

Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA): Federal law requiring reasonable accommodations and fair evaluation of employees with disabilities. Evaluation forms must not discriminate against protected disabilities.

Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA): Federal protection against age discrimination for workers 40 and older. Peer evaluations must not include age-biased criteria or language.

EEOC Guidelines: Equal Employment Opportunity Commission guidelines for fair employment practices, including evaluation procedures and documentation requirements.

Employee Privacy Rights: Legal requirements for protecting employee privacy and personal information in evaluation processes, including confidentiality of peer reviews.

State Labor Codes: State-specific employment laws that may affect the content and process of peer evaluations, varying by jurisdiction.

Documentation Standards: Legal requirements for maintaining accurate, objective, and complete records of peer evaluations for compliance and potential legal defense.

Anti-Retaliation Provisions: Legal protections against retaliation for honest peer feedback, requiring safeguards in the evaluation process.

Defamation Considerations: Legal requirements to prevent potential defamation claims, ensuring evaluations are factual, objective, and properly documented.

Performance Metrics Requirements: Legal standards for objective, measurable, and non-discriminatory performance criteria in employee evaluations.

Teams

Employer, Employee, Start Date, Job Title, Department, Location, Probationary Period, Notice Period, Salary, Overtime, Vacation Pay, Statutory Holidays, Benefits, Bonus, Expenses, Working Hours, Rest Breaks,  Leaves of Absence, Confidentiality, Intellectual Property, Non-Solicitation, Non-Competition, Code of Conduct, Termination,  Severance Pay, Governing Law, Entire Agreemen

Find the exact document you need

Training Feedback Form For Employees

A US-compliant employee training feedback form for collecting and evaluating training program effectiveness while adhering to federal employment regulations.

find out more

Worker Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant employee performance evaluation document for systematic assessment of work performance, goal achievement, and professional development planning.

find out more

Peer To Peer Evaluation Form

US-compliant peer evaluation form for structured colleague feedback and performance assessment, aligned with federal employment laws.

find out more

Employee Work Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant formal document for evaluating employee performance, documenting achievements, and setting professional development goals.

find out more

Restaurant Staff Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant performance evaluation form for restaurant staff, designed to assess employee performance while adhering to federal and state labor laws.

find out more

Posture Evaluation Form

A HIPAA-compliant medical form used in the US healthcare system for documenting patient posture assessments and related findings.

find out more

Evaluation Form Webinar

A U.S.-compliant webinar feedback collection form for gathering participant evaluations and insights.

find out more

Character Evaluation Form For Teachers

A U.S.-compliant assessment tool for evaluating teachers' professional conduct and character attributes in educational settings.

find out more

Appraisal Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant document for conducting and recording employee performance evaluations.

find out more

Letter Requesting Performance Evaluation

A formal request for employee performance evaluation in the U.S., outlining evaluation criteria and timeline.

find out more

Staff Self Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant document enabling employees to assess their own job performance and professional development within organizational guidelines.

find out more

Induction And Orientation Feedback Form

A US-compliant feedback form for evaluating new employee orientation and induction experiences, designed to assess and improve organizational onboarding processes.

find out more

Peer Assessment Form

A US-compliant structured form for peer-to-peer employee performance evaluation and feedback, incorporating rating scales and qualitative assessment criteria.

find out more

Training Course Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant standardized form for collecting and evaluating participant feedback following training courses, aligned with federal educational and employment regulations.

find out more

Employee Raise Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant document for evaluating employee performance and determining salary increases.

find out more

Job Appraisal Form

A U.S.-compliant document for formal employee performance evaluation and documentation.

find out more

Employee Performance Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant document for formal evaluation of employee performance, documenting achievements, goals, and development areas.

find out more

Feedback Form For Tourist

A U.S.-compliant tourist feedback collection form designed to gather visitor experiences and satisfaction data while maintaining privacy and accessibility standards.

find out more

Staff Performance Evaluation Form

A US-compliant employee performance evaluation document used for assessing work performance, setting goals, and documenting professional development discussions.

find out more

Special Event Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant documentation tool for assessing event execution, safety compliance, and outcomes.

find out more

Preschool Director Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant evaluation form for assessing preschool director performance across key competency areas.

find out more

Post Evaluation Form For Webinar

A U.S.-compliant feedback collection form for webinar participants, meeting federal and state privacy requirements.

find out more

Performance Evaluation And Planning Form

A U.S.-compliant document for evaluating employee performance, setting goals, and planning professional development.

find out more

Performance Appraisal Form For Hr Executive

A U.S.-compliant evaluation document for assessing HR executive performance, competencies, and achievements against established objectives.

find out more

Letter Of Disagreement Of Performance Appraisal

A formal U.S. document used to contest and seek revision of a performance appraisal, while maintaining compliance with employment laws.

find out more

Homeschool Portfolio Evaluation Form

A U.S. legal document for evaluating and documenting homeschool student progress and state compliance.

find out more

Executive Director Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant assessment tool for evaluating executive director performance and leadership effectiveness.

find out more

Designer Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant evaluation form for assessing designer performance and professional development.

find out more

Supplier Performance Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant structured form for evaluating and documenting supplier performance across key metrics including quality, delivery, and cost management.

find out more

Training Evaluation Form For Trainees

A U.S.-compliant form for evaluating trainee performance and training program effectiveness.

find out more

Online Event Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant digital feedback collection form for online event participants.

find out more

New Supplier Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant evaluation form used to assess and qualify potential suppliers' capabilities and compliance status.

find out more

Meal Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant standardized form for evaluating food quality, safety, and service in food service operations.

find out more

Evaluation Forms

U.S.-compliant evaluation form template for conducting structured assessments in professional and educational contexts, adhering to federal and state requirements.

find out more

Civil Service Performance Appraisal Form

A U.S. government standardized form for evaluating civil service employee performance in accordance with federal regulations.

find out more

Athlete Performance Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant standardized form for evaluating and documenting athlete performance and capabilities.

find out more

Manager Evaluation Form

A US-compliant form for evaluating managerial performance and documenting leadership assessment.

find out more

Pharmacy Technician Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant evaluation tool for assessing pharmacy technician performance and competency.

find out more

Worship Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant assessment tool for evaluating religious worship services and their leaders within religious organizations.

find out more

Instructor Performance Evaluation Form

A U.S.-compliant form for evaluating teaching professionals' performance and effectiveness in educational settings.

find out more
See more related templates

Genie’s Security Promise

Genie is the safest place to draft. Here’s how we prioritise your privacy and security.

Your documents are private:

We do not train on your data; Genie’s AI improves independently

All data stored on Genie is private to your organisation

Your documents are protected:

Your documents are protected by ultra-secure 256-bit encryption

We are ISO27001 certified, so your data is secure

Organizational security:

You retain IP ownership of your documents and their information

You have full control over your data and who gets to see it

2 Docs LeftAccess Now