Handling Title Issues and Encumbrances When Buying Commercial Premises for Sale

Handling Title Issues and Encumbrances When Buying Commercial Premises for Sale

Acquiring commercial premises for sale represents a significant investment for any business, and the due diligence process extends far beyond evaluating the physical condition of the property. Title issues and encumbrances can derail transactions, create unexpected liabilities, and expose your organization to costly legal disputes. Understanding how to identify, evaluate, and resolve these concerns is critical for executives and commercial teams responsible for property acquisitions.

Understanding Title and Why It Matters

Title refers to the legal right to own, use, and transfer property. When you purchase commercial premises for sale, you are not simply buying a building or land, you are acquiring a bundle of legal rights. A clear title means the seller has the full legal authority to transfer those rights without any competing claims or restrictions that could interfere with your intended use of the property.

Title problems can emerge from various sources: unpaid liens, easements that grant others access to the property, restrictive covenants that limit how you can use the premises, or even errors in public records. These issues can remain hidden until a title search uncovers them, making thorough investigation essential before closing any transaction.

Common Title Issues in Commercial Real Estate

Several types of title defects frequently appear in commercial property transactions. Liens represent one of the most common problems. A lien is a legal claim against the property for unpaid debts, which might include unpaid taxes, contractor bills from previous construction work, or judgments from lawsuits. Liens typically must be satisfied before the property can be transferred with clear title.

Easements grant third parties specific rights to use portions of the property. Utility companies may hold easements to maintain power lines or water pipes. Neighboring properties might have easement rights for access roads or shared driveways. While some easements are routine and acceptable, others can significantly interfere with your plans for the property.

Encroachments occur when structures or improvements from adjacent properties cross onto the property you intend to purchase, or when existing structures on your prospective property extend beyond its legal boundaries. These physical intrusions can create disputes with neighbors and complicate future development plans.

Restrictive covenants are recorded agreements that limit how property can be used. These might prohibit certain types of businesses, restrict building heights, or mandate specific architectural standards. Covenants can be particularly problematic if they conflict with your intended commercial use.

The Title Search and Title Insurance Process

A comprehensive title search examines public records to identify any claims, liens, or other issues affecting the property. This process typically reviews deeds, court records, property indexes, and other documents to trace the chain of ownership and uncover potential problems. Title companies or real estate attorneys conduct these searches as part of the transaction process.

Even the most thorough title search cannot guarantee absolute certainty. Errors in public records, undisclosed heirs, forged documents, or other hidden defects might not surface during the search. This is where title insurance becomes valuable. Title insurance protects buyers and lenders against financial loss from title defects that existed before the purchase but were not discovered during the title search.

Two types of title insurance policies exist: owner's policies and lender's policies. If you finance the purchase, your lender will require a lender's policy to protect their investment. An owner's policy protects your equity in the property and is typically purchased at closing for a one-time premium.

Resolving Title Issues Before Closing

When title issues surface during due diligence, several resolution strategies are available. For liens, the most straightforward approach involves requiring the seller to pay off and release the lien before closing. The purchase agreement should specify that the seller must deliver clear title, and closing proceeds can be structured to ensure outstanding liens are satisfied from the seller's funds at closing.

Easements require careful evaluation. Determine whether the easement materially affects your intended use of the property. Utility easements along property boundaries may be acceptable, while an easement granting public access through the middle of your planned building site would be problematic. If an easement creates significant issues, you might negotiate with the easement holder to relocate or terminate it, though this can be time-consuming and expensive.

For encroachments, survey documentation is essential. A current survey will identify any boundary issues. Minor encroachments might be resolved through boundary line agreements with neighbors. More significant encroachments may require removing structures, purchasing additional land, or walking away from the transaction if resolution is not feasible.

Restrictive covenants demand careful legal review. Your attorney should assess whether the covenants are enforceable and whether they conflict with your business plans. In some cases, covenants may be outdated or no longer enforceable. If covenants would prevent your intended use, you might seek releases from the parties who benefit from the restrictions, though this is not always possible.

Negotiating Purchase Agreement Protections

Your purchase agreement should include specific provisions addressing title issues. A title contingency clause allows you to review the title commitment and object to any unacceptable exceptions. This contingency gives you the right to terminate the agreement if title problems cannot be resolved to your satisfaction.

The agreement should clearly state that the seller must convey marketable title, free from liens and encumbrances except those specifically accepted by the buyer. Define what constitutes acceptable exceptions, such as standard utility easements or recorded covenants that do not interfere with your intended use.

Include provisions specifying how title defects will be handled. The seller should have a reasonable period to cure defects, but you should retain the right to terminate if issues cannot be resolved. Consider whether you want the option to close despite certain defects in exchange for a purchase price reduction or escrow holdback.

For complex transactions involving properties held in trust arrangements, a Land Trust Deed may be relevant to review as part of understanding the ownership structure and ensuring proper transfer of beneficial interests.

Special Considerations for Commercial Properties

Commercial premises for sale often present unique title challenges compared to residential properties. Zoning compliance is critical. Verify that the property's current use is legally conforming and that your intended use is permitted under applicable zoning regulations. Non-conforming uses might be grandfathered but could be lost if the property remains vacant or if you make substantial changes.

Environmental liens can attach to commercial properties due to contamination issues. If environmental problems exist, government agencies may place liens for cleanup costs. Environmental due diligence should run parallel to your title review, as environmental liabilities can be as significant as traditional title defects.

Mechanic's liens from contractors or suppliers who performed work on the property can arise even after your purchase if the work was completed before closing but the lien was recorded afterward. Most states allow contractors a window of time to file liens for work already performed. Title companies typically require affidavits from sellers confirming no recent work has been done, or they may require extended coverage or holdbacks to address this risk.

For properties subject to existing leases, tenant rights function as encumbrances that will survive your purchase. Review all leases carefully as part of due diligence. Tenant leases may contain options to purchase, rights of first refusal, or other provisions that could affect your ownership rights.

Working with Professionals

Navigating title issues requires a team of qualified professionals. A real estate attorney should review the title commitment, identify problematic exceptions, and advise on resolution strategies. Attorneys can negotiate with lien holders, draft curative documents, and ensure your purchase agreement adequately protects your interests.

Title companies conduct the title search and issue title insurance. Choose a reputable title company with experience in commercial transactions. The title commitment they issue will list all exceptions to coverage, which your attorney should review carefully.

Surveyors provide current surveys showing property boundaries, easements, encroachments, and improvements. A survey is essential for identifying physical issues that may not be apparent from record review alone. Ensure the survey meets the standards required by your lender and title company.

For transactions where the deal structure involves complex arrangements, having proper documentation in place is essential. If issues arise that require terminating the transaction, a Cancellation of Property Sale Agreement may be necessary to formalize the termination and address any deposit or earnest money considerations.

Due Diligence Timeline and Practical Steps

Structure your due diligence period to allow adequate time for title review and issue resolution. A typical commercial transaction might include 30 to 60 days for due diligence, though complex properties may require more time. Order the title commitment and survey immediately after contract execution to maximize the time available for addressing problems.

Review the title commitment promptly when received. Do not wait until the end of your due diligence period to identify issues. Communicate objections to the seller in writing, specifying which exceptions are unacceptable and what curative action is required. Document all negotiations regarding title issues.

Coordinate with your lender throughout the process. Lenders will have their own title requirements, and issues acceptable to you might not be acceptable to your financing source. Understand your lender's requirements early to avoid surprises near closing.

Post-Closing Title Considerations

After closing, maintain your title insurance policy and related documents in a secure location. If title issues arise later, you will need these documents to file a claim. Record all relevant documents promptly after closing, including the deed and any easements or agreements negotiated as part of the transaction.

Monitor your property for potential future encumbrances. Stay current on property taxes to avoid tax liens. If you make improvements, ensure contractors are paid promptly and obtain lien waivers to prevent mechanic's liens. Be aware of any prescriptive easement issues that could arise if you allow others to use portions of your property over extended periods.

For properties held through complex ownership structures, periodic review of trust arrangements and related documentation ensures continued clarity of ownership. If circumstances change and trust arrangements need to be unwound, a Deed of Termination of Trust may be required to properly transfer property out of trust ownership.

Risk Management and Decision Making

Not all title issues are deal-breakers. Your decision-making process should weigh the severity of identified problems against the overall value of the transaction. Minor easements or covenants that do not affect your intended use may be acceptable. Significant liens or restrictions that fundamentally impair the property's value or utility may justify terminating the transaction.

Consider the cost and feasibility of curing defects. If the seller can clear a lien for a reasonable amount, requiring that cure as a closing condition makes sense. If resolving an issue requires protracted litigation or negotiation with uncooperative third parties, the risk and delay may outweigh the benefits of proceeding.

Quantify risks where possible. If an encumbrance reduces property value, consider negotiating a purchase price reduction rather than requiring removal of the encumbrance. If title insurance will cover a particular risk, evaluate whether that coverage provides adequate protection.

Document your analysis and decision-making process. When presenting recommendations to senior leadership or boards, clearly explain identified title issues, proposed resolutions, associated costs and risks, and your rationale for proceeding or terminating the transaction. This documentation protects you and provides a record for future reference.

Purchasing commercial premises for sale requires careful attention to title and encumbrance issues that can significantly impact your investment. By conducting thorough due diligence, working with experienced professionals, negotiating appropriate contractual protections, and making informed risk assessments, you can navigate these challenges and complete transactions that serve your organization's long-term interests. The time and resources invested in properly addressing title issues before closing will pay dividends by avoiding costly disputes and ensuring you receive the full bundle of property rights you expect when acquiring commercial real estate.

How do you clear a title defect on commercial property before closing?

Clearing a title defect before closing requires identifying the specific issue through a title search and working with your title company to resolve it. Common defects include unpaid liens, unresolved easements, or missing signatures on prior deeds. Start by obtaining a detailed title report and prioritizing issues that could block your transaction. For liens, negotiate payoffs with creditors or request the seller satisfy them before closing. Boundary disputes or easement problems may require surveys, quiet title actions, or recorded agreements. In some cases, a Cancellation Of Property Sale Agreement may be necessary if defects cannot be resolved within your timeline. Work closely with a title attorney to ensure all corrective documents are properly recorded and your title insurance policy covers any remaining risks.

What should you do if an easement affects your commercial property purchase?

If an easement affects commercial premises for sale, start by obtaining a detailed title report to understand the scope, location, and beneficiary of the easement. Assess whether the easement restricts your intended use, such as access, utilities, or parking. Consult with a real estate attorney to evaluate potential risks and negotiate adjustments to the purchase price or terms if the easement materially impacts value. In some cases, you may request the seller to modify or terminate the easement before closing. If the easement is unavoidable, ensure your purchase agreement includes appropriate disclosures and protections. Document all findings and decisions carefully to avoid future disputes or operational disruptions.

How do you negotiate who pays for title insurance on commercial premises?

Negotiating who pays for title insurance depends on local market customs, deal leverage, and transaction structure. In many commercial real estate transactions, the buyer traditionally pays for the owner's title policy, but this is negotiable. Start by researching customary practices in your state or region, as conventions vary widely. During negotiations, consider the overall deal economics: a seller eager to close may agree to cover title insurance costs, while a competitive market may shift this expense to the buyer. You can also propose splitting the cost or offsetting it against other terms, such as purchase price adjustments or repair credits. Clearly document the agreed allocation in the purchase agreement to avoid disputes. If the transaction involves complex title issues or requires additional endorsements, address who bears those extra costs upfront. Understanding these dynamics helps you manage costs effectively when evaluating commercial premises for sale.

Genie AI: The Global Contracting Standard

At Genie AI, we help founders and business leaders create, review, and manage tailored legal documents - without needing a legal team. Whether you're drafting documents, negotiating contracts, reviewing terms, or scaling operations whilst maintaining a lean team, Genie's AI-powered platform puts trusted legal workflows at your fingertips. Try Genie today and move faster, with legal clarity and confidence.