How to Review a Software as a Service Agreement: A Legal Checklist for Buyers

How to Review a Software as a Service Agreement: A Legal Checklist for Buyers

Reviewing a software as a service agreement requires a careful balance between understanding technical requirements and protecting your organization from legal and financial risk. As a buyer, you need to ensure the agreement covers operational needs while limiting exposure to unexpected costs, service failures, and data security issues. This checklist walks you through the key provisions that demand your attention before signing.

Service Scope and Performance Standards

The foundation of any software as a service agreement is a clear definition of what the vendor will deliver. Start by confirming that the agreement specifies the exact services, features, and functionalities included in your subscription. Vague language like "industry-standard uptime" or "reasonable support" creates room for dispute later.

Look for service level agreements (SLAs) that include measurable performance metrics. These should cover uptime percentages, response times for support requests, and resolution timeframes for critical issues. A strong SLA will specify consequences when the vendor fails to meet these standards, typically in the form of service credits or the right to terminate without penalty.

Pay attention to exclusions and limitations. Many vendors exclude scheduled maintenance windows from uptime calculations or limit support to certain hours. Understanding these boundaries helps you assess whether the service matches your operational requirements.

Data Ownership and Security Obligations

Your data remains one of your most valuable assets, and the software as a service agreement must clearly state that you retain ownership of all data you input or generate through the platform. The vendor should have limited rights to use your data only as necessary to provide the service.

Security provisions deserve close scrutiny. The agreement should require the vendor to maintain appropriate administrative, physical, and technical safeguards that comply with relevant regulations in your industry. Ask for specific commitments around encryption, access controls, and regular security audits. If you operate in a regulated sector like healthcare or finance, verify that the vendor will sign a Business Associate Agreement or meet other compliance requirements.

Data portability and retrieval rights matter when the relationship ends. Confirm that the agreement allows you to export your data in a usable format and specifies how long the vendor will retain your data after termination. Some vendors delete data immediately, while others maintain it for 30 to 90 days.

Pricing Structure and Hidden Costs

Software pricing models vary widely, and the initial subscription fee rarely tells the whole story. Review how the vendor calculates charges, whether based on users, transactions, data storage, or other metrics. Understand the billing frequency and payment terms.

Watch for provisions that allow unilateral price increases. Some agreements permit annual increases tied to inflation or at the vendor's discretion with minimal notice. Negotiate caps on increases or require mutual agreement for changes beyond a specified threshold.

Identify additional costs that may apply for implementation, training, data migration, customization, premium support, or exceeding usage limits. These extras can significantly increase your total cost of ownership.

Term, Renewal, and Termination Rights

The initial term and renewal provisions control how long you remain committed to the vendor. Many software as a service agreements automatically renew for successive periods unless you provide advance notice, often 30 to 90 days before the renewal date. Missing this deadline can lock you into another full term.

Examine your termination rights carefully. Beyond expiration of the term, you should have the ability to terminate for cause if the vendor breaches material obligations, particularly around security, performance standards, or confidentiality. Some agreements also allow termination for convenience with adequate notice, though this may trigger early termination fees.

Consider how termination impacts your operations. The agreement should include transition assistance obligations, requiring the vendor to cooperate during migration to a new provider. If you need flexibility in contract duration, reviewing templates like a 30 Days Notice To Terminate Contract can provide useful reference points for standard termination language.

Limitation of Liability and Indemnification

Most software as a service agreements include provisions that limit the vendor's financial liability for service failures, data loss, or other problems. These caps typically range from the fees paid in the preceding 12 months to a fixed dollar amount. While some limitation is standard, ensure it does not leave you underprotected for catastrophic failures.

Certain liabilities should remain unlimited or subject to higher caps, including breaches of confidentiality, data security failures, intellectual property infringement, and gross negligence. Negotiate to carve these out from standard limitations.

Indemnification clauses specify who bears responsibility when third parties bring claims. The vendor should indemnify you against claims that the software infringes intellectual property rights. You may be asked to indemnify the vendor for claims arising from your data or your use of the service in violation of the agreement.

Intellectual Property Rights

The software as a service agreement should grant you a license to use the software and related materials during the subscription term. This license should be broad enough to cover all anticipated uses, including by your employees, contractors, and potentially customers or partners.

Clarify ownership of customizations, configurations, or integrations developed during the relationship. Standard agreements often give the vendor ownership of all modifications, but you may negotiate shared rights or ownership of custom work you fund.

If you plan to integrate the SaaS platform with other systems, confirm that the agreement permits such integrations and that any APIs or technical documentation needed are included or available.

Warranties and Disclaimers

Vendors typically provide limited warranties that the service will perform substantially as described in documentation and that they have the right to provide the service. Beyond these basics, most software as a service agreements disclaim other warranties, including implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose.

While some disclaimers are standard, push back on overly broad language that eliminates all vendor accountability. The vendor should warrant that the service will not contain malware, that it will comply with applicable laws, and that it will not infringe third-party rights.

Compliance and Regulatory Requirements

If your business operates under specific regulatory frameworks, the software as a service agreement must address compliance obligations. This includes requirements under GDPR for international data transfers, HIPAA for healthcare information, SOC 2 for security controls, or industry-specific regulations.

Request copies of relevant compliance certifications and audit reports. The agreement should permit you to audit the vendor's compliance or require the vendor to provide regular attestations.

Dispute Resolution and Governing Law

The agreement will specify which state's laws govern interpretation and how disputes are resolved. Vendors often choose their home state, but you may negotiate for a neutral jurisdiction or your own location, particularly for high-value agreements.

Many agreements require arbitration rather than litigation. Understand whether arbitration is binding, where it would occur, and how costs are allocated. While arbitration can be faster and cheaper than court proceedings, it also limits your ability to appeal unfavorable decisions.

Key Questions to Ask Before Signing

As you complete your review, ask yourself these critical questions:

• Can we meet our business objectives if the vendor only delivers the minimum performance standards specified in the SLA?
• What happens to our operations if the vendor experiences a major outage or security breach?
• Do we have adequate rights to retrieve and use our data if we terminate the agreement?
• Are we comfortable with the vendor's liability limitations given our risk exposure?
• Can we afford unexpected costs from usage overages, price increases, or early termination fees?
• Does the agreement allow us to scale up or down as our needs change?

Negotiation Leverage and Priorities

Not every provision is equally negotiable. Vendors offering standardized cloud services typically resist changes to core terms, particularly around liability, warranties, and intellectual property. However, you often have more flexibility on pricing, service levels, data rights, and termination provisions.

Prioritize the issues that matter most to your organization. If data security is paramount, focus negotiation energy there rather than on less critical terms. Document any verbal promises or commitments in writing, either in the agreement itself or in a signed addendum.

For organizations regularly engaging software vendors, developing a standard playbook of required terms and fallback positions streamlines the review process. Templates similar to a Software Consulting Agreement can provide helpful frameworks for professional services that often accompany SaaS implementations.

Reviewing a software as a service agreement thoroughly before signing protects your organization from operational disruptions, unexpected costs, and legal disputes. By systematically working through service definitions, data rights, pricing, termination provisions, and liability limitations, you position your organization to maximize value while minimizing risk. When in doubt, consult with legal counsel experienced in technology transactions to address complex issues specific to your situation.

What red flags should you look for when reviewing vendor SaaS contracts?

Watch for automatic renewal clauses that lock you in without clear exit options, especially those requiring notice periods of 90 days or more. Be wary of vague service level commitments that lack specific uptime guarantees or remedies for outages. Unlimited liability caps on the vendor's side, combined with broad indemnification obligations on yours, create serious financial exposure. Pay close attention to data ownership and portability terms that restrict your ability to retrieve or migrate data upon termination. Beware of unilateral modification rights that allow the vendor to change terms, pricing, or functionality without your consent. Finally, scrutinize termination provisions that make it difficult or costly to exit the relationship, including excessive termination fees or data deletion timelines that are unreasonably short.

How do you assess termination rights in software subscription agreements?

Termination rights define how and when either party can exit a software as a service agreement. Start by identifying termination for convenience provisions, which allow you to end the contract with advance notice, typically 30 to 90 days. Check whether termination triggers automatic data deletion or allows a transition period. Review termination for cause clauses, ensuring they cover material breaches like service outages, security failures, or missed service level agreements. Confirm that notice requirements are realistic and that you receive refunds for prepaid but unused subscription periods. Pay attention to post-termination obligations, including data retrieval rights, confidentiality duties, and any survival clauses. Understanding these provisions protects your business if the vendor relationship deteriorates or your needs change.

What questions should you ask vendors before signing a SaaS contract?

Before signing a software as a service agreement, ask vendors about their data security practices, backup procedures, and disaster recovery plans. Clarify service level commitments, including uptime guarantees and response times for support requests. Understand pricing structures, including any potential fee increases, overage charges, and renewal terms. Inquire about data ownership, export options, and what happens to your data after termination. Request details on their compliance certifications relevant to your industry. Ask about integration capabilities with your existing systems and whether customization is available. Finally, discuss termination rights, notice periods, and any exit assistance they provide to ensure you can transition smoothly if needed.

Genie AI: The Global Contracting Standard

At Genie AI, we help founders and business leaders create, review, and manage tailored legal documents - without needing a legal team. Whether you're drafting documents, negotiating contracts, reviewing terms, or scaling operations whilst maintaining a lean team, Genie's AI-powered platform puts trusted legal workflows at your fingertips. Try Genie today and move faster, with legal clarity and confidence.