Software as a Service Contract Review Checklist: Red Flags Every Buyer Should Know

Software as a Service Contract Review Checklist: Red Flags Every Buyer Should Know

Signing a software as a service contract without careful review can expose your business to unexpected costs, service disruptions, and legal liabilities. SaaS agreements differ significantly from traditional software licenses, and the subscription model introduces unique risks that demand attention before you commit. Understanding the red flags in these contracts helps you negotiate better terms and avoid costly surprises down the road.

Vague Service Level Agreements

One of the most critical sections in any software as a service contract is the Service Level Agreement, or SLA. This defines the performance standards the vendor promises to meet, including uptime guarantees, response times, and support availability. A red flag appears when the SLA uses vague language like "commercially reasonable efforts" or "best endeavors" without specific metrics.

Look for concrete commitments. An acceptable SLA should specify uptime percentages, typically 99.5% or higher for mission-critical applications. It should also detail what happens when the vendor fails to meet these standards. Without clear remedies such as service credits or the right to terminate, you have little recourse when performance falls short.

Pay attention to how uptime is calculated. Some vendors exclude scheduled maintenance windows, which can be substantial. Others measure availability differently than you might expect. If your business operates globally, confirm that the SLA covers all regions where you need service, not just the vendor's primary data center location.

Unlimited Liability Caps

Most software as a service contracts include liability limitations that cap the vendor's financial responsibility for damages. While some limitation is standard, extremely low caps present a serious red flag. When a vendor limits liability to the fees paid in the prior month or quarter, you may find yourself unable to recover meaningful damages if their service failure causes significant business harm.

Review whether different caps apply to different types of claims. Some contracts distinguish between direct damages, indirect damages, and specific scenarios like data breaches or intellectual property infringement. The vendor may accept higher liability for security incidents while maintaining strict caps on other claims.

Consider whether the liability cap makes sense relative to your potential exposure. If a service outage could cost your business hundreds of thousands in lost revenue, but the vendor's liability is capped at a few thousand dollars, you face an unbalanced risk allocation. This may warrant negotiation or purchasing additional insurance coverage.

Problematic Data Ownership and Portability Terms

Your data is one of your most valuable business assets. A software as a service contract should clearly state that you retain ownership of all data you input into the system. Red flags include language suggesting the vendor gains ownership rights, perpetual licenses, or broad rights to use your data beyond what's necessary to provide the service.

Data portability becomes crucial when you need to switch vendors or bring operations in-house. Contracts that fail to address how you can export your data, or that charge excessive fees for data extraction, create vendor lock-in. Look for provisions guaranteeing you can retrieve your data in standard formats without unreasonable cost or delay.

The contract should also specify what happens to your data after termination. How long will the vendor retain it? Will they securely delete it upon your request? Ambiguous data retention terms can create compliance problems, especially if you operate in regulated industries with strict data handling requirements.

Automatic Renewal and Termination Restrictions

Many SaaS agreements include automatic renewal clauses that extend the contract term unless you provide advance notice of non-renewal. While common, these become red flags when the notice period is unreasonably long, such as 90 or 180 days before the renewal date. This makes it difficult to evaluate alternatives or negotiate better terms.

Examine termination rights carefully. Contracts that only allow termination for cause, with narrowly defined grounds, leave you trapped even if the service no longer meets your needs. Look for provisions allowing termination for convenience with reasonable notice, or at least at the end of each renewal term. If you are reviewing similar termination provisions in other contexts, resources like the Termination Letter With Notice Period template can provide useful reference points.

Watch for financial penalties tied to early termination. Some vendors charge substantial fees if you exit before the contract term ends. While some termination fee may be reasonable, charges exceeding the remaining contract value or extending beyond a few months of fees should raise concerns.

Inadequate Security and Compliance Provisions

Security breaches and compliance failures can devastate your business. A software as a service contract must address how the vendor protects your data and maintains compliance with applicable regulations. Red flags include generic security language without specific commitments to industry-standard practices.

The contract should specify security certifications the vendor maintains, such as SOC 2, ISO 27001, or industry-specific standards. It should address encryption both in transit and at rest, access controls, and security monitoring. For regulated industries, confirm the vendor will sign a Business Associate Agreement for HIPAA compliance or meet other sector-specific requirements.

Look for provisions requiring the vendor to notify you promptly of security incidents affecting your data. The contract should define timelines for notification and outline the vendor's responsibilities in responding to breaches. Vague incident response terms leave you unprepared when problems occur.

Unclear Pricing and Hidden Fees

Pricing transparency is essential in any software as a service contract. Red flags appear when the contract leaves room for unexpected charges or fails to clearly define what's included in the base fee. Watch for provisions allowing unilateral price increases during the contract term, especially without limits on the increase amount.

Common hidden fees include charges for implementation, training, data migration, customer support beyond basic levels, API calls exceeding certain thresholds, or additional users beyond initial counts. The contract should itemize all potential fees and specify the circumstances triggering them.

Pay attention to how price increases are handled at renewal. While vendors typically reserve the right to adjust pricing for subsequent terms, annual increases tied to specific indices or capped at reasonable percentages are more predictable than unlimited discretion to raise prices.

Weak Intellectual Property Protections

The software as a service contract should clearly address intellectual property rights. You need assurance that using the service won't infringe third-party IP rights and that the vendor will defend you if infringement claims arise. Contracts lacking indemnification for IP infringement present significant risk.

Review whether you're granting the vendor any rights to intellectual property you create using their platform. Some contracts include broad licenses allowing vendors to use, modify, or even sublicense customer-created content or configurations. Unless necessary for service delivery, such provisions should be narrowed or removed.

If you're developing custom integrations or configurations, clarify who owns that work product. Ambiguity about ownership of customizations can create problems if you later want to move to a different platform or if the vendor relationship ends poorly.

Missing Change Management Procedures

SaaS vendors regularly update their platforms, sometimes introducing changes that disrupt your workflows or eliminate features you depend on. Contracts that give vendors unlimited discretion to modify the service without notice create operational risk. Look for provisions requiring advance notice of material changes and the opportunity to test updates before they go live in your production environment.

The contract should address what happens if an update breaks critical functionality or integration with your other systems. Do you have the right to roll back to the previous version? Will the vendor provide support to resolve compatibility issues? Without these protections, you may face unexpected downtime or forced workarounds.

Insufficient Support Terms

When problems arise, responsive support becomes critical. A software as a service contract should specify support availability, response times for different severity levels, and available support channels. Red flags include support limited to email only, business hours support for systems you use around the clock, or slow response time commitments for urgent issues.

Clarify whether premium support requires additional fees and what that enhanced support includes. Some vendors provide only basic support in the base subscription, reserving phone support, dedicated account managers, or faster response times for higher-tier plans.

The contract should also address how the vendor handles bug fixes and when you can expect resolution of reported issues. Open-ended timelines or provisions stating the vendor will fix bugs "in a future release" without commitment leave you vulnerable to prolonged service problems.

Reviewing Before You Sign

A thorough software as a service contract review protects your business from unnecessary risk and ensures you understand exactly what you're purchasing. Don't hesitate to negotiate terms that present red flags. Vendors often have flexibility to adjust contract language, especially for larger deals or longer commitments.

Consider having legal counsel review the contract, particularly for enterprise agreements or services handling sensitive data. The cost of legal review is minimal compared to the potential exposure from problematic contract terms. When dealing with complex service arrangements, templates like the Master SaaS Agreement can provide a useful starting point for understanding standard terms and identifying areas requiring customization.

Document any verbal promises or commitments the vendor makes during negotiations. If the sales team promises features, integrations, or service levels, ensure those commitments appear in the written contract. Verbal assurances that contradict or expand upon contract terms typically aren't enforceable.

Taking time to identify and address red flags in your software as a service contract creates a foundation for a successful vendor relationship. Clear terms reduce disputes, align expectations, and ensure both parties understand their rights and obligations. The effort invested in careful contract review pays dividends throughout the relationship, protecting your business and enabling you to maximize value from your SaaS investment.

How do you identify unfavorable auto-renewal terms in SaaS contracts?

Unfavorable auto-renewal terms can lock your organization into unwanted commitments and unexpected costs. Start by checking the notice period required to cancel before renewal: anything less than 60 days is restrictive, and some vendors demand 90 or 120 days. Look for clauses that automatically increase pricing upon renewal without your explicit consent. Watch for terms that extend the contract for the same duration as the original term, which can trap you in multi-year commitments. Verify whether the software as a service contract allows you to downgrade users or services at renewal, or if you are locked into the same tier. Finally, confirm that termination rights are clearly stated and not buried in fine print, ensuring you retain control over your subscription lifecycle.

What termination rights should you look for when reviewing a SaaS agreement?

Strong termination rights protect your business from being locked into underperforming or problematic software as a service contracts. Look for provisions allowing termination for convenience with reasonable notice, typically 30 to 90 days. Ensure you can exit immediately if the vendor breaches material terms, including service level failures, security incidents, or repeated downtime. Confirm you retain the right to terminate if the vendor undergoes a change of control or bankruptcy. Equally important are data retrieval rights: the agreement should guarantee you can export your data in a usable format before termination takes effect. Avoid automatic renewal clauses without clear opt-out windows. Review any financial penalties for early termination carefully, as excessive fees can trap you in unsuitable arrangements. Clear termination provisions give you leverage and flexibility as your business needs evolve.

How can you protect your company from vendor lock-in provisions in SaaS contracts?

Protecting your company from vendor lock-in starts with negotiating clear data portability and exit rights in your software as a service contract. Insist on provisions that guarantee you can export all your data in standard, usable formats at any time, without penalty or excessive fees. Negotiate reasonable termination notice periods and avoid automatic renewal clauses that trap you in multi-year commitments. Request assistance with data migration during the transition period and ensure the vendor will continue providing access for a defined period after termination. Review any proprietary format requirements carefully, as these can make switching vendors costly. Finally, avoid contracts that impose steep early termination fees or require you to continue paying for unused services. Taking these steps upfront gives you flexibility and leverage should you need to change providers down the road.

Genie AI: The Global Contracting Standard

At Genie AI, we help founders and business leaders create, review, and manage tailored legal documents - without needing a legal team. Whether you're drafting documents, negotiating contracts, reviewing terms, or scaling operations whilst maintaining a lean team, Genie's AI-powered platform puts trusted legal workflows at your fingertips. Try Genie today and move faster, with legal clarity and confidence.